The purpose of advertising.

“Advertising is what you do when you cannot get there in person”

This has been a pretty regularly heard quote over my 40 years in this business, attributed to Fairfax Cone, one of the founders of Foote Cone & Belding advertising. It  remains one of the foundations of good (i.e. effective) communication weather it be paid-for  media space,  or one of the newer forms of “content marketing” on the web.

How come most of the advertisers I have heard/seen over the Christmas period never heard it?

I make that assertion based on the crap that passes as advertising over this period, almost all of it based on price and a transparent “1/2 yearly”, or “Clearance sale” type claim. Also, the businesses owner is  often used as the mouthpiece,  usually not a media friendly person. Nothing to attract me apart from a cheap price, certainly nothing to persuade me that the product will do anything to solve my problems, just price.

Problem with price being the only reason to buy, is that it just becomes a race to the bottom, and as Seth Godin has pointed out, the risk here is that you just might win. 

If you could talk one  on one to all the potential customers, would you still say the same thing as you are saying in your advertising?

If the answer is “No” better rethink your approach for the good of your long term pocket.

God help the NBN

In the communication revolution going on currently, the infrastructure to carry it all is vital, but how relevant will the 2010 infrastructure be to the world that greets it when it is finally completed roll-out in, when?, what was the last projection? ever?. The world is changing almost daily, the NBN as conceived by our  political masters will be obsolete before it is 10% implemented. 

In the October issue of “Wired” magazine is a fascinating analysis of the “Tech War” going on  between Apple, Google, Amazon, and Facebook. It is a must read for anyone in business, it puts a competitive context around the maneuvering we all see happening, but do not necessarily connect the dots.

We, the Australian taxpayers,  are making a multi-generational investment in the NBN, billions of dollars spent by those well known, fast moving,  tech savvy innovators in Canberra. Lets hope they know what is going on outside the cocooned environment of the   “bush Capital that are all so pleased to live in.   

Somehow I doubt they have any idea, and that is truly scary, and there will be a whole lot more of this sort of failure, and the accompanying spin before anyone in Canberra admits to a huge boo boo.

Pavlov’s customers.

We are in the middle of the post Christmas sales, an orgy of discount opportunities for consumers as retailers rush to clear stock, and take advantage of the behavior consumers exhibit every new year, “buy, buy, grab the discount”.

Whoops?

Have we trained customers to expect great deals post Xmas, do they put off spending at full price till the post  Xmas period, not because the deals are great, but because they have been trained to do so? 

Clearly the answer is yes, customers have been trained, just like Dr Pavlov demonstrated.

So, what else can customers be trained to do? When you think about it, the list gets pretty long.

Switch brands indiscriminately

Demand discounts

Be impatient and unforgiving

Expect free service, whilst getting a discount price

24 hour delivery

Limitless warranty

The list goes on, but to each, there is a positive side, customers can be trained to stay with the one brand, not to expect discounts and unreasonable service and warranty, not all of them, but usually enough to make the investment worthwhile, as the alternative is to go broke being the cheapest to all, rather than delivering genuine value to those who are prepared to pay for it.

What are you training your customers to expect?

 

What’s coming for 2012?

It is the time of year for predictions and reviews, so here is my shot. Three general predictions, and one very specific one, followed by a review of my predictions of this time last year.

    1. The barriers to communication are falling so quickly, that a raft of tools are emerging that will change the way we consume. Collaborative Consumption is emerging as an economic driver that  will change the mechanics of many industries, and create new ones. Companies like Zipcar remove the need to own a car, particularly useful for inner city residents, Swaptree replaces the sale of Ebay with a swap, something you have but no longer need being swapped with someone with the opposite.
    2. Small is good!. Starting a new business has never been easier, and they are popping up all over the place, replacing and renewing all sorts of services. All that gets in the way of all this new activity is the institutional barriers in place from last century. If you need a bit of money to fund a good idea, and the family and friends, the traditional source, are wary, try Kickstarter.com, where money is pledged to good ideas.
    3. The wisdom of the crowd is slowly being recognised, but the pace is accelerating rapidly. This idea, first comprehensively articulated by James Suroweicki, the New Yorker columnist some years ago is gaining amazing traction in management practice as its self evident truths are incorporated into activity. The next step is to assemble this wisdom from the electronic fingerprints we all leave across the net. Scary to some from a privacy perspective, enormously productive from the factory floor to the boardroom and political forums.
    4. The Mad Monk , Opposition leader Tony Abbott will not make it to the end of 2012, but will be replaced by Malcolm Turnbull, who appears to be on of the few in the Parliament who actually listens to the facts, and acknowledges that ideological solutions to the complex problems we face are just too simplistic to work, but that we need a consistent philosophical foundation to the decisions that are made, rather than a response to a focus group. 

 

 

At the end of 2010 I made some observations and predictions, so how did I go? Generally, the trends identified here I believe will continue,  with the exception of the first one, which is now appears likely to be very wide of the mark.

    1. We may regret the increase in “touch” devices as we use them to replace human contact. Jury is still out, the growth of touch devices has been amazing during the year, and shows no sign of lessening,  but there is little evidence that my concern about the humanity in relationships being eroded is valid. Score 2/10.
    2. Global retailing takes over. It seems the e-tailing revolution is really here, now you can find and buy just about everything on the net,  from books and electronics to whitegoods, cars, and even love.  Score 7/10. marked myself down a bit because it was so obvious.
    3. Net advertising will overtake traditional advertising. I  have seen conflicting numbers, so who really knows, but I suspect it has happened, and when you add in the growth of “content” posted on sites like u-tube, that are not paid advertising, but have a marketing objective, there is no doubt paid advertising in “traditional” media is now behind advertising/advertorials on the net . Score 7/10.
    4. Social media comes of age. Got that right, the quickest growing demographic on social media is 50 plus, often connecting with scattered grandchildren, then discovering  SM is a great tool for all sorts of other things. Score 9/10.
    5. The cloud rolled in. Again, got it right, the hype around the cloud appears to be turning into investment, not just so institutions can reduce their costs, but because change is so rapid, it is now easier to keep up on the cloud. Most are finding it is not cheaper, the money just moves from the balance sheet to the P&L, but far more flexible, and responsive to change. Score 9/10
    6. Data mining will gain momentum. This happened, and is still happening, but slower than I thought it would. I suspect the growth in the cloud, (5) and crowdsourcing  (7) will provide significant momentum. Score 6/10
    7. Crowdsourcing will emerge from the shadows. This is certainly a trend that accelerated through the year, and is still gaining momentum. Everything from NPD, to project management, graphic art, sales lead identification, and customer service delivery. Score 7/10, just because it it taking a bit longer than I expected.
    8. Two speed Australia became accepted, even if two speed now appears to be a much more complicated mix than just 2 speeds. The  added complication is the financial crisis in the Eurozone, and the knock-on impacts that could have on Australia’s economy as exports from to Europe and the US from China slow. This is a truly scary scenario. Score 7/10.
    9. Climate change and the political response. With the exception of Australia, with Bob Brown calling the shots in Canberra, climate change fell down the agenda in developed countries in the face of financial woes. Companies may be working slowly to adjust their  activity mix, but politicians are more concerned with re-election, and are taking populist positions rather than taking the really hard decisions that will alienate large parts of electorates. Score 6/10
    10. The push for regulation. Got that right, often by stealth, regulation is coming back as a strategy option for governments everywhere. In Australia the most obvious is our workplace legislation. Got that right, 9/10. In December, 2011 it was announced that “Fair Work Australia” would undergo the promised review of its effectiveness, chaired by the new minister Bill Shorten, who has already announced his view that we are leading the world in workplace regulation. My bullshit meter hit overdrive when I saw the press release, as it is clear that the regulations are stifling innovation, risk taking and productivity, and are simply an acknowledgement to the “left” whichever party they belong to . There are several others, like the so called “Road safety Remuneration Bill” which is really just a government sponsored grab for power by the TWU, and promises to cost the community heaps, and put even more small transport operators out of business, but are travelling under the radar.

Overall, I give myself a pretty good pass mark.

 

Hope 2012 is a good one for you.

Allen

 

Why not Organic?

An obtuse end of year thought, considering the problems the Government is having with its Green partner in policy. 

A convergence of trends, organic, free range, sustainable, all the other adjectives, food is all the rage, why not re-brand those horrid, smelly, carbon producing fossil fuels as organic? 

Well, they are aren’t they, formed from trees, nice and green, nurtured by the earth for millennia, how could the good Senator Brown possibly disagree?

The carbon tax, could be renamed a “green tax”, recognising the origins of fossil fuels, only reasonable I think, in fact, it should be a central plank of the new party platform. Hats and whistles please.

Give Julia something to think about over the break, apart from gay marriage and how to deliver the budgie a wedgie for Christmas.

See you next year.