How do you identify those who might emerge as competitors?
Might as well ask what the weather will be like next week, or next year. Just looking out the window will not help much, as things tend to change pretty quickly.
So it is with identifying potential competitors and the new value propositions they offer. However, like forecasting the weather, there are indicators, models that can be applied that will at least throw some light on the question.
It seems to me that there are three perspectives to this question, best described by the usual ‘think outside the box’ metaphor.
- Competitors from inside the current box
- Competitors from outside the current box
- Competitors from outside the postcode.
Leaving aside the great benefit of hindsight, it is generally pretty easy to see potential competitors from inside your current box. You are already rubbing up against them in some way, technically, geographically; you might have common customers for products with slightly different characteristics or value propositions. There is always the possibility for someone in an adjacent market expanding their control of the supply chain vertically, which will bring them into competition with you. Now, there are many digital tools that will assist the process from google key word searches, to explicitly looking at where similar offerings are emerging via social media. In addition, these often obvious emerging competitors are usually the ones your sales force are always on about, as they are the dog that got their homework, often by making cut price offerings of stripped down products to your customers.
Identifying potential competitors from outside the box is a bit harder. it is also increasingly important, as the barriers to entry to many industries have been blown away.
To do this well requires focussed critical thinking, and understanding of the drivers of purchase by your customers, the evolution of those purchase drivers, and the current sources of purchase friction encountered by customers. This takes some commitment to longer term strategic thinking.
Identifying those potential competitors from outside the postcode in a disciplined manner is extraordinarily hard, and beyond the resources of any SME I have ever seen. It not only requires the sort of time for deep thinking and scenario analysis available only to large organisations, it requires a very ‘absorbent’ innovation culture, one that accepts the inevitability of major disruption, and explicitly goes about discovering what those sources of disruption might be, and then disrupting themselves.
This sort of out of the postcode thinking opens up your mind to potential competitors. It also opens your mind to potential sources of future growth for yourself. As a result, having as a part of your strategic thinking and review process an explicit and disciplined ideation process should be a part of every strategic exercise and review.
These three perspectives all have in common the requirement that any enterprise, to be successful competitively over the long term, needs to ‘understand itself’ and be very sensitive to changes in their operating and competitive environment. Then, they have to be able to respond, which is often the hardest bit because it demands change. In the case of out of the postcode opportunities, radical change, and a high level of risk tolerance are required. As Sun Tzu is recorded as having said ‘know others and know thyself, and you will not be endangered by innumerable battles”.
The header illustration comes form the extensive StrategyAudit toolbox.
